Before staring the recipe, assess the spiciness of your jalapeños. To manage the heat level, incorporate them gradually.
Set aside 2 tablespoons CHEDDAR CHEESE, 1 tablespoon BACON, and a sprinkle of CHIVES for the final coating.
Place CREAM CHEESE, remaining CHEDDAR CHEESE, BACON, JALAPENOS, CHIVES, and GARLIC POWDER in a mixing bowl. Stir until smooth and well-combined.
Add splashes of MILK and stir to adjust the texture so that it's slightly creamy, yet still cohesive.
Season the mixture with SALT and PEPPER to taste.
Transfer the cheese ball mixture to a piece of plastic wrap. Pull up the sides and wrap it into a ball shape.
Refrigerate the cheese ball for one hour.
To prepare for serving, combine the reserved cheese, bacon, and chives in a wide bowl.
Remove the plastic wrap and roll the cheese ball in the mixture to coat the surface.
To serve, rest the cheese ball at room temperature for 30 minutes. Pair it with crackers, bread, crostini, pita chips, or pretzels.
To store, cover and refrigerate the cheese ball up to 3 days.
Notes
Visit the blog post above for step-by-step photos.
Avoid touching your face while working with jalapeño peppers and ensure you thoroughly wash your hands and cutting surfaces afterward. For added protection, consider using nitrile gloves.
Add small amounts of Serrano peppers for an extra kick.
Make it vegetarian by simply omitting the bacon.
Use extra sharp white cheddar cheese for a white, sharper-flavored jalapeno cheese ball.
Experiment with different coatings, such as toasted panko or finely chopped nuts, for added texture.
To make ahead, follow the recipe up to step 5, cover and refrigerate the cheese ball until 30 minutes before serving, and resume the recipe instructions.